If everything is meaningless, isn't it also meaningless to start a party? Isn't it a performative contradiction for a nihilist to do anything at all – start a party, for instance? Why don't you just kill yourselves, if everything is meaningless? What is a nihilist? Are there different ways of being a nihilist? Are there different factions or wings within NFP? If everything is meaningless, do you have to be indifferent to everything? You come across as very negative and grumpy. Are you? What would you change if you got into power? Wouldn't NDP be the correct abbreviation for the Nihilistic Democratic Party? What will you do if one of your candidates is elected to a local council or to Copenhagen City Council? What will you do if you win an outright majority? Are you terrorists, like the Russian nihilists? Where do you stand on democracy? Aren't you violating the logical principle of non-contradiction? Isn't nihilism just the same as anarchism? If you rebel in hell to show Lucifer how God felt, doesn't that make you Christians? What is your position on Nietzsche's critique of nihilism? What is your position on Jacob Haugaard?
Yes, it is meaningless. It is just no more meaningless than anything else one could be doing. Since there is no purpose to one's life anyway, why not start a party?
No. It is only a contradiction if you are a fundamentalist. The fundamentalist subjects nihilism to a purity test so narrow that nobody can pass it, as though one could only call oneself a socialist if one gladly shared all one's beer and one's toothbrush with everyone, or a Christian only if one were a monk with clean thoughts. On the fundamentalist reading, nihilism cannot be practised at all: every action is a performative contradiction, since to act is to prefer something, and to prefer is to pass a value judgement. Even breathing ascribes a value to life. The only consistent nihilist, on this view, is a vegetable on a ventilator. NFP does not recognise the fundamentalist ban on action. One does not have to be a vegetable to be a nihilist! The nihilist has grasped that it is all meaningless anyway. He may therefore do exactly as he pleases, so long as he never comes to believe that his actions have a purpose, or to hope that they matter.
Why would we? In a meaningless universe, taking one's own life is neither more nor less meaningless than anything else one might do. There is no reason to grant suicide a privileged status among the meaningless acts on offer. A nihilist can just as well start a party, smear himself in liver pâté or go to work as kill himself; it makes no difference! Suicide in fact looks a little stupid when one is free to do as one pleases, since nothing matters anyway. Even on the fundamentalist reading of nihilism (see above), suicide is no more nihilistic than anything else. Suicide, too, is a performative value judgement on life; a negative one, but a value judgement all the same. We live in an absurd universe in which death is the one certain outcome. We are condemned to death – not suicides. The universe can do its own hangman's work. We will not be its useful idiots!
A nihilist is a person who has realised that nothing is valid and nothing matters. Any attempt to specify a "nihilist essence", or a definition in terms of necessary and sufficient conditions, will therefore not survive the nihilist's own merciless analysis. There is accordingly no authoritative description of the "true nihilist" to serve as a normative ideal, and no scale on which anyone's nihilism can be found wanting.
Yes, there are different types of nihilist. Nihilism has worn many faces, forms and formulations through the ages, and no single formulation holds a monopoly on "genuine nihilism". World literature, for instance, offers several figures who have been canonised as nihilists. Camus' portrait of the absurd man in "The Myth of Sisyphus" is a portrait of a nihilist: "The absurd man glimpses a burning and ice-cold universe, transparent and bounded, in which nothing is possible but everything is given; beyond it lie chaos and darkness. He can resolve to live in such a universe and draw from it his strength, his courage to renounce hope, and his will to bear witness to the possibility of living without consolation." Ivan Karamazov in Dostoevsky's "The Brothers Karamazov" is another canonical nihilist (canonised by Camus, among others, in "The Rebel"). Ivan's nihilism consists in the refusal of salvation. Even if there were a God and a rational metaphysical order that gave the suffering of innocent children a higher purpose, Ivan would decline the offer. The ticket to heaven is too dear when the fare is paid in the tears of suffering children. Ivan's nihilism is not indifference; it is rage against, and a no to, a world he refuses to accept. Ole Jastrau in Tom Kristensen's 1930 novel "Havoc" is another nihilist hero. He makes a conscious decision to go to the dogs, since man has no soul anyway and it therefore makes no difference. There is room within nihilism not only for difference but for outright contradiction.
Yes. Unanimity is not a value NFP subscribes to. NFP is a broad church. At rock bottom, the ceiling is high! NFP has two wings: right-nihilists and left-nihilists. Both set out from Nothing, but where the left-nihilists see Nothing as the point of departure, the right-nihilists see Nothing as the destination. Broadly speaking, left-nihilism starts from the death of God and the normative vacuum that follows. There is no normative yardstick, and there is no purpose to existence for us to realise. That existence has no purpose, because the world does not care, leaves one free to do as one pleases, since there is no goal one could miss anyway. A number of left-nihilists live out this absurd freedom through heavy drinking, drugs and casual fornication – in some cases combined with party work. Right-nihilism starts from the gnostic credo that the world is evil. What is, is evil – and has to go. Destruction as a goal comes from the nihilist right, which wants revenge on a universe that has always pissed on everyone and everything. When we count Schopenhauer as a right-nihilist, for example, it is partly because for him the purpose of human existence is to annihilate the universe by annihilating the will that produces the representations (illusions) we take for reality. Behind the representations there is Nothing. And Nothing is better! (See, if you like, the last chapter of "The World as Will and Representation".) The division into two "wings" is itself a crude simplification of the range of views nihilism can accommodate, but it is very practical for communications purposes.
No. A nihilist is not necessarily a cold-blooded sociopath. There are other ways of being a nihilist than the alienated hero of Camus' "The Stranger". One can be furious that it is all meaningless and that existence has no purpose. One can also be painfully torn between indignation that the world is unacceptable and the realisation that it is not going to get better. Or one can cheerfully seize the absurd freedom that comes with giving up all hope, and let out a long, loud, scornful laugh at a universe that is, frankly, too silly for words.
No. Morale in NFP has never been higher. Once you have abandoned all hope of things getting better, you might as well enjoy life. When existence has no purpose, you are free. You cannot fail where you cannot win. Enjoy it!
Change has never been change for the better – only change to more of the same. NFP is like Barack Obama: the status quo with a human face.
Yes. But NFP just sounds better! "I am afraid we are not rid of God because we still have faith in grammar." Friedrich Nietzsche
Our first priority will be to deliver on our pledges. This is about leaving nihilistic fingerprints on every decision the council takes. Vote NFP and you can be certain of two things: that your vote is wasted, and that it has been wasted cheerfully. Saying no to everything does not mean a nihilist councillor cannot be a visible presence on the streets.
First and foremost, we will find it amusing. We will laugh at the end of politics. Then we will deliver on our pledges and dissolve the party.
No. Terrorism requires that you believe in something. Even the Russian nihilists only sought the collapse of society because they hoped something better would follow. Something they could believe in. In any case, terrorism does not work. When terror strikes, people start believing that their values are valid. Values can only be dismantled through a democratic process and a change in hearts and minds.
NFP holds democracy sacred. Democracy is democratic – and "democratic" always polls well. Everyone without exception claims to be fighting for democracy – from which it follows, as a matter of logic, that NFP is too. The only justification for a democratic party's existence is our unique Danish democracy, which has given us everything we are today. Danish nihilism must be democratic nihilism! We fully respect the views and opinions of voters who do not agree with NFP's manifesto. We encourage them to start parties of their own, so that their views, too, can become part of the free and fair democratic debate.
The objection runs as follows: nihilism refutes itself on purely logical grounds, because it rejects everything. If nihilism rejects everything, it must also reject truth, and so it falls to the liar paradox: "There are no true sentences." If the sentence is true, it is false. [A → not-A]. A self-contradiction, in violation of the principle of non-contradiction. Answer: Fuck non-contradiction in an absurd world that cannot in any case be made intelligible by a bivalent logic, in which the semantic content of a sentence is reduced to the simple pair: true or false. The principle of non-contradiction may have some bearing on a heated debate about whether the cat is on the mat, but when the subject is something slightly more interesting, such as the basic conditions of human existence, logic's naive hope of preserving truth through valid inference becomes a shackle on thought. The world as it appears in the crown jewel of the natural sciences, quantum mechanics, is incidentally indifferent to the principle as well: there are German cats in small boxes that are dead and alive at the same time. It is worth recalling here Nietzsche's critical naturalisation of logic and the principle of contradiction. In The Gay Science, aphorism 111, Nietzsche writes that identity and the principle of contradiction rest on an "illogical tendency" to treat as equal what is merely similar. This was useful for survival; as a binding principle of reason it has no authority whatever. Life comes before logic. Reason and logic are secondary to the existential situation of human beings. Our situation is that we are condemned to death – and the paradoxes of formal logic are of limited relevance to a man who has already been condemned to death. The principle of contradiction is therefore not high on the party's agenda.
No. Anarchism holds out the hope of a better world without state or authority, in which humanity's true nature can flourish in non-coercive, self-organising communities. We nihilists know that hope for what it is: naive. It overlooks the fact that the injuries of existence are inflicted not by society but by the ontological structure of man and the universe.
We look forward to finding out.
Nietzsche's relationship to nihilism is widely misunderstood. Many have taken him at his word when he declares himself an opponent of nihilism, and treat nihilism as something to be overcome. But NFP understands Nietzsche better than he understood himself! It is true that Nietzsche says nihilism is what the overman must overcome. Read the philosophy, however, and the relationship turns out to be rather more complex. For Nietzsche, nihilism consists in denying life its value because one cannot bear suffering, and inventing instead a "true world" in which one hopes to be saved in the afterlife. Hope of salvation is how the weak betray life, out of bitterness at suffering. On this account Christianity, too, is nihilistic. Nietzsche's conception of nihilism, however – which, on Nietzsche's own terms, is only one perspective on nihilism – in fact allows the overman, paradoxically enough, to be regarded as a cheerful nihilist himself. What Nietzsche is fighting is hope. Hope is an expression of weakness, bitterness and ressentiment. The active human being, who stands beyond good and evil and can create new perspectives, has no need of hope. Only the reactive human being needs it: he hopes that the others will leave him alone if he calls them evil, and that sooner or later it will all stop being such a drag. It is the hope of a life without suffering and an existence without injury that the overman must overcome. The overman can will his life – every bit of suffering included – repeated in exactly the same way, again and again, for all eternity. To be without hope is to will one's own suffering life. In the Nihilistic Democratic Party we have put that hope behind us. An intense life without hope of salvation, in which only one's actions performatively posit values in a universe that is absolutely indifferent and worthless, is also the life of the nihilist. The overman is simply a nihilist in a good mood.
Jacob Haugaard is one of the great political talents of his generation. In 1994 the comedian was actually elected to the Danish parliament for the Union of Consciously Work-Shy Elements, Denmark's answer to the Monster Raving Loony Party, on a single pledge: 8 hours of leisure, 8 hours of rest and 8 hours of sleep. NFP can only admire a politician of such clear sight. Haugaard's labour-market policy was nihilistic, and he had grasped the one decisive truth: that Danish politics is irrelevant anyway. Haugaard himself has said that he wanted to show "that the meaning is that there is no meaning!" NFP therefore openly acknowledges its Haugaardian inheritance.
Regrettably, Haugaard was unable to hold on to his nihilistic insight into the irrelevance and impotence of politics once he had taken his seat. The other politicians succeeded in starving his nihilistic protest of the oxygen of publicity, insisting on the lie that Danish politics matters and is not merely a game of spinning one's way to power.
Haugaard therefore left the job unfinished. NFP intends to finish it. We pledge that no pressure from the other politicians and opinion-formers will silence our nihilistic protest once we are in office.